Blog Details Shape

Testing Pyramid: A Successful Approach to End to End testing

Pratik Patel
By
Pratik Patel
  • Aug 16, 2024
  • Clock
    6 min read
Testing Pyramid: A Successful Approach to End to End testing
Contents
Join 1,241 readers who are obsessed with testing.
Consult the author or an expert on this topic.

Imagine confidently launching your software, knowing that every button click, data transfer, and user interaction works perfectly—no surprises, no last-minute bugs. This level of assurance doesn't happen by chance; it’s the result of accurate End-to-End (E2E) Testing.

But what exactly does end-to-end testing mean? How does it ensure that your application not only works but grows under real-world conditions? And most importantly, what are the steps and tools that make this testing approach crucial?

In this blog, we are diving deep into the concept of end-to-end testing and also know about its best practices and why it’s the ultimate safeguard for your software’s success.

The Testing Pyramid builds quality from the ground up — Unit to E2E tests, with manual tests at the peak.

More base = fewer bugs, faster releases.

Testing Pyramid

While the Testing Pyramid shows the structure, it's equally important to understand how much, how fast, and who owns each layer of testing.

Here’s a detailed breakdown:

Type No. of Test Execution Speed Stability Written by
Unit 70% Fast Solid Developers
Integration 20% Medium Good QA/Developers
UI (E2E) 10% Slow Fragile QA

1. Unit Tests

  • Coverage: 70%
  • Execution Speed: Fast — they run quickly because they test small, isolated pieces of code (like individual functions or classes).
  • Stability: Solid — since they don't depend on external systems (like databases or APIs), they're highly reliable.
  • Written by: Developers — these are created during development to validate that each component behaves as expected.

2. Integration Tests

  • Coverage: 20%
  • Execution Speed: Medium — slower than unit tests because they check how different components interact (e.g., a service talking to a database).
  • Stability: Good — generally reliable, but can become flaky if external dependencies aren't properly managed.
  • Written by: QA / Developers — a collaboration between dev and QA ensures systems are wired together correctly.

3. UI (E2E) Tests

  • Coverage: 10%
  • Execution Speed: Slow — they simulate real user journeys across the entire application, involving multiple systems.
  • Stability: Fragile — even small UI changes can cause tests to fail, making maintenance important.
  • Written by: QA — these tests focus on ensuring that the overall user experience works as intended.

What is End-to-End (E2E) Testing?

End-to-end (E2E) testing represents a software testing strategy that evaluates entire application workflows from beginning to end. E2E testing helps components communicate properly in their system framework to deliver true user perspectives about software delivery.

E2E testing is conducted after integration testing and before user acceptance testing (UAT) to identify system-wide issues early. Simulating real user scenarios verifies that the application functions as expected across different modules, databases, and third-party integrations.

For example, a user logs into the OTT app to watch a movie, verifying successful login functionality. They browse the library, ensuring smooth navigation and search capabilities. 

After selecting a movie, they test video playback, checking for seamless streaming and adjustable settings. The user pauses and exits, confirming that their progress is saved in the “Continue Watching” section.

{{cta-image}}

Why should you do end-to-end testing?

End-to-end (E2E) testing should be adopted to ensure your application is confident in performing in a real-world environment. Here’s why you should make it a priority:

  1. Ensure full workflow functionality: E2E testing shows that all the elements of an application are compatible through end-to-end user scenarios or cases.
  2. Early detection of integration issues: E2E testing helps identify bugs and issues that arise when different modules or systems interact.
  3. Enhances user experience: E2E tests use real-world scenarios to make sure the application behaves as intended for the end user, hence ensuring a smooth, resilient experience.
  4. Reduce post-release problems: Thorough end-to-end testing minimizes the risk of defects and failures in the production environment.
  5. Support continuous delivery: Automated end-to-end (E2E) tests are essential to CI/CD because they guarantee that new code modifications will not conflict with already-existing functionality.

Key Components of End-to-End Testing

End-to-end (E2E) testing involves several key components that work together to ensure the entire application functions seamlessly. Here are the main components:

Key components of E2E testing

1. User actions workflow

E2E testing closely mimics real users’ activities and scenarios.

  • Develop test cases that replicate how users navigate through the application.​
  • Test various features and user interactions.​
  • Ensure the application responds as anticipated in normal usage scenarios.​

2. System dependencies

E2E testing verifies the communication of various segments of the application.

  • Ensure that all data is stored in the right format and can be retrieved when required.​
  • Confirm that other services the application relies on are properly implemented and work fine.​
  • Validate successful interaction with both internal and external APIs when exchanging data.​

3. Data integrity

Maintaining data integrity is vital in E2E testing.​

  • Ensure that data remains consistent and accurate throughout the user's workflow.
  • Verify that data is transferred correctly between system components.
  • Check that data is properly inputted into databases and displayed in the user interface.​

Types of End-to-End Testing

End-to-end testing ensures that your software works as expected across every component, interface, and user interaction. Here are the key types of E2E testing, each designed to validate a specific part of the system’s reliability, performance, or compliance.

1. Functional Testing

Functional testing verifies that each feature works according to the specified requirements. It checks real-world user flows and ensures that business logic behaves correctly across all modules.

2. Performance Testing

This type assesses your application’s responsiveness, stability, and scalability under load. It helps identify performance bottlenecks and ensures the app can handle high traffic smoothly.

3. Usability Testing

Usability testing focuses on the user experience. This ensures that the application is intuitive, accessible, and easy to navigate. This is essential for maximizing user satisfaction and adoption.

4. Security Testing

Security testing evaluates how well the application protects data and resists malicious attacks. It checks for vulnerabilities, misconfigurations, and ensures compliance with security best practices.

5. Compatibility Testing

This ensures the app works consistently across different devices, browsers, operating systems, and network conditions. This is crucial for delivering a seamless experience to all users.

6. Compliance Testing

Compliance testing ensures that the software adheres to legal, regulatory, and organizational standards. This is particularly important in industries like FinTech, healthcare, and SaaS.

What are the Steps for Performing End-to-End Testing?

As a crucial part of software development, end-to-end testing ensures that the entire application functions as intended from start to finish. Here is a breakdown of the steps involved:

Steps for E2E testing

1. Analyze the requirements

The primary first step is to understand all the application business goals as well as the use cases and workflow processes. This initial step’s goal is to identify which items should be tested and which ones should not be missed.

2. Setup test environment

The second step: establish a testing environment close to the actual environment. To this end, one has to establish the hardware, software, network, and data that will give the best result possible for the test conditions.

3. Design end-to-end test cases

The third task, which is the secondary target of the second task, is to create fine-grained test cases that mimic end-to-end user journeys. Test the software for all potential edge cases along with essential features and different scenarios.

4. Execute test cases

As for the fourth step, identify test case execution in your test environment using test automation tools like Selenium, Cypress, Playwright, or Appium. This will allow one to track the process and keep an eye out for any anomalies.

5. Verify the results

The fifth step is to compare the predicted test results with the actual ones to see how the application carries out the intended operations. This should always be done to record any failures or discrepancies for future reference.

6. Report and fix bugs

The final step is to note the found defects, assign them based on severity, and with your development team, resolve them. Test the application once again to verify that the implemented repairs have solved the issues without causing new problems.

Top 5 Tools for End-to-End Testing

For performing E2E testing, these tools offer robust solutions for E2E testing, each with unique strengths suited to different testing needs and environments. We mention the top 5 best end-to-end testing tools:

Tools for E2E testing

1. Selenium

Selenium is an open-source tool implemented for browser automation testing, and it is among the most used tools. Known for its flexibility, Selenium 4 features advanced functionalities that enhance browser automation capabilities. It supports more than one programming language, like Java, Ruby, C#, or Python, and can be implemented on different browsers and operating systems. Selenium is rather flexible, and it is fairly often utilized for web app testing. 

2. Cypress

Cypress is a fast-moving tool for carrying out end-to-end testing of web applications. It is designed for the new JavaScript framework and has a rich set of built-in tools to write and run tests. Cypress provides the capabilities of real-time reload, automatic waiting, and it has a built-in test result panel. 

3. WebdriverIO

WebDriverIO is one of the most popular open source testing tools designed for the testing of graphical user interface web applications. It employs the WebDriver protocol for controlling the web browsers for end-to-end testing. It supports several browsers like Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, Apple Safari, and Microsoft Edge, among others.

4. Appium

Appium is an open-source tool that allows mobile app testing for native, hybrid and web applications. It is compatible with both iOS and Android and enables the tester to write their tests in popular languages. Using Appium, it is possible to provide a cross-platform and powerful solution for mobile app end-to-end testing.

5. Playwright

Playwright is a testing tool that lets you execute test automation on any device and browser located in the cloud. It includes most of the modern web frameworks and provides numerous opportunities for debugging and monitoring the test results and reporting the outcomes of tests.

For a deeper comparison between two of the top end-to-end testing tools, Playwright and Cypress, check out our blog. It provides insights on their strengths, differences, and how to choose the right tool for your project needs.

{{cool-component}}

Best Practices of End-to-End Testing

End-to-end (E2E) testing is one of the most important tests that is aimed at the proper work of the application from the beginning to the end. To maximize its effectiveness, here are some best practices you should follow:

Prioritize Key User Flows

  • Start by focusing on the most critical workflows like login, checkout, and payments.
  • Divide complex processes into testable small processes.
  • Cutting out the redundant tests won’t be helpful.

Avoid Unnecessary Exception Testing

  • Error handling is tested in another fashion.
  • Apply unit and integration tests for checking system operations after errors.
  • Avoid E2E test scenarios that belong to another type of test.

Reduce UI Test Flakiness

  • Minimize network delay-based test failures due to dynamic elements.
  • Load elements before using them.
  • Test business logic by APIs, when possible, not through UI tests.

Run Tests in Parallel

  • Speed up execution by running the tests simultaneously esp. in CI/CD pipelines.
  • Leverage cloud-based platforms for cross-browser and mobile testing.
  • Focus on high-risk and frequent tests for efficiency.

{{cta-image-second}}

Conclusion

End-to-end testing is essential for ensuring that your application functions seamlessly from start to finish. By simulating real-world user interactions and verifying the entire workflow, E2E testing helps identify and resolve issues that could impact the user experience. It validates that all components, including those verified during unit testing, work together as expected, ensuring a smooth and reliable application.

By working together with the Alphabin team, one can guarantee that the software is efficient, safe, and functional on every operating system. Allow Alphabin to assist you in providing software quality via end-to-end testing and various software testing services.

Something you should read...

Frequently Asked Questions

How to perform end-to-end (E2E) testing?
FAQ ArrowFAQ Minus Arrow

To perform E2E Testing

  • Plan user scenarios based on real workflows.
  • Set up a test environment similar to production.
  • Write and automate test cases using tools like Cypress or Selenium.
  • Run tests across browsers and devices.
  • Analyze and fix any failures.
  • Retest to ensure full functionality.
When should E2E testing be performed?
FAQ ArrowFAQ Minus Arrow

E2E testing should be performed after system integration is complete but before the product goes live, and also after major updates, to ensure the entire user journey works as expected across all components.

What is an example of end-to-end?
FAQ ArrowFAQ Minus Arrow

An example of End-to-End (E2E) testing is:

  • Scenario: A user logs into a banking app, transfers money to another account, and then logs out.
  • E2E Testing: This test would check that the login process, money transfer, and logout all work together smoothly, ensuring that the entire user journey is successful and error-free.
How do you measure end-to-end testing?
FAQ ArrowFAQ Minus Arrow

To measure End-to-End (E2E) testing, focus on these key metrics:

  • Test Coverage: Percentage of the application covered by tests.
  • Defect Detection Rate: Number of defects found during testing.
  • Pass/Fail Rate: Success rate of executed test cases.
  • Execution Time: Time taken to complete tests.
  • Defect Leakage: Defects missed in testing and found in production.

About the author

Pratik Patel

Pratik Patel

Pratik Patel is the founder and CEO of Alphabin, an AI-powered Software Testing company.

He has over 10 years of experience in building automation testing teams and leading complex projects, and has worked with startups and Fortune 500 companies to improve QA processes.

At Alphabin, Pratik leads a team that uses AI to revolutionize testing in various industries, including Healthcare, PropTech, E-commerce, Fintech, and Blockchain.

More about the author

Discover vulnerabilities in your  app with AlphaScanner 🔒

Try it free!Blog CTA Top ShapeBlog CTA Top Shape
Join 1,241 readers who are obsessed with testing.

Discover vulnerabilities in your app with AlphaScanner 🔒

Blog CTA Top ShapeBlog CTA Top ShapeTry it free!

Blog CTA Top ShapeBlog CTA Top Shape
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Join 1,241 readers who are obsessed with testing.
Consult the author or an expert on this topic.
Join 1,241 readers who are obsessed with testing.
Consult the author or an expert on this topic.
Pro Tip Image

Pro-tip

Focus on automating key user journeys in end-to-end testing, like login and checkout flows, to maintain stability as your app evolves. Complement automation with manual testing for complex cases.

Alphabin enhances your testing process with expert strategies and advanced tools, ensuring your end-to-end testing is both effective and efficient, delivering a seamless user experience every time.

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article:

Related article: