.svg)
You run your test suite, and a test fails. You re-run it—now it passes. No code changes, just random failures. Annoying, right? But here’s the scary part: flaky tests don’t just waste time—they slowly break trust in your entire testing process.
Flaky tests show inconsistent results across runs. They create unreliable outcomes, hurting test accuracy. These tests may report false positives or negatives. False negatives flag non-existent defects, wasting time.
False positives lead to real issues being overlooked, which threatens quality. In both cases, workflow is disrupted and releases are delayed. Uncorrected flakiness reduces the team's confidence in software testing. It also hides real bugs, which increases risk.
The real question is, "Can we afford not to fix them?" Let’s break down why they’re so dangerous—and how to stop them for good.
{{cta-image}}
What is a Flaky Test?
A flaky test is an automated test that sometimes passes and sometimes fails for the same code and test logic. These unreliable tests are not good for your test suite at all, and they can silently waste hours debugging your tests.
Factors of a Flaky Test
- Inconsistent Results: It fails and passes across multiple runs without code change in the same test.
- Unpredictable Failures: The test outcomes seem random and are usually related to timing, environment, or external dependencies.
- Works on My Machine: This passes locally but fails in CI/CD pipelines.
- Failure Disappears on Retry: Rerunning the test fixes the issue.
Common Causes of Flaky Tests
As companies adopt continuous testing, automation becomes critical. Faster test execution boosts efficiency, but flaky tests can undermine reliability.
When automation suites fail unpredictably, they produce inconsistent results. Left unchecked, these tests disrupt development, delay releases, and risk undetected bugs slipping into production. This often happens due to the following reasons:
1. Concurrency and Race Conditions
- Asynchronous operation and multi-threaded code tests may fail occasionally.
- Random timing variations of various threads with shared resources can lead to unpredictable results.
2. External Dependencies
- Tests based on third-party APIs, databases, or network calls can fail because of latencies, outages, or rate limits.
- Test failure can be caused by network instability or slow responses.
3. Non-Deterministic Behaviors
- If the tests depend on time, random values, or system states, their results may be inconsistent.
- These include using timestamps, generating random data, and executing code on which the machine conditions dictate different behavior.
4. Unstable Testing Environments
- Tests can behave unpredictably due to variations in hardware or OS, CPU, and memory availability.
- Consequently, running the tests in different environments (local vs. CI/CD) can reveal differences.
5. Insufficient Assertions or Flawed Test Logic
- Weak assertions may lead to continuously passing tests.
- Test conditions that are poorly written may cause tests to pass when they shouldn’t or fail at the edge cases.
Impact of Flaky Tests on CI/CD
Unstable tests are a nuisance to the CI/CD process and they lead to a waste of time and other resources needed for the process.
Time and Resource Waste
Flaky tests use up a lot of time and resources when integrated into CI/CD pipelines. The flaky test failure causes a chain reaction of unneeded operations in the system.
- Rerunning the Test: To reproduce flaky tests, the test needs to be run multiple times, which wastes time and computational resources.
- Debugging: Developers spend excessive time trying to debug flaky tests to find the root causes of their failed tests.
- False Positives: Flaky tests cause tests to fail out of a flaky issue instead of a real code bug.
How to Identify a Flaky Test?
Monitoring test reliability over time is a must to detect flaky tests. Rerunning failed tests, using dedicated tools to analyze patterns, and logging thoroughly. Detect early and continue to have a stable CI/CD pipeline. Here are some effective methods:
Rerunning Failed Test
To detect flakiness, it is a simple but effective thing to rerun failed tests a few times. If a test fails inconsistently in the same conditions, this is a strong indication of instability.
This is useful when you run tests in isolation repeatedly to find out what the failure is based on the test or external factors.
Parallel Test Execution Analysis
Flaky tests that pass in isolation and fail in parallel test execution can also be exposed. These resource conflicts, race conditions, and dependency problems arise when an application tests concurrently. These failures are monitored to identify instability.
Testing in Varied Environments
Testing in multiple environments exposes failures that are caused by OS, browser, or network differences and increases the reliability of testing.
Analyzing Tests Logs and Results Systematically
Test logs and results help in finding out hidden dependencies and timing issues. Patterns of failures can be revealed using error messages, timestamps, and things like execution order. Keeping track of test results helps to find sporadic failures over time.
Automated Flaky Test Detection Tools
Flaky test detection can be automated. Tools like Flaky Test Detector, Jenkins Flaky Test Plugin, and Gradle Flaky Test Handling track test history and highlight inconsistencies. In this way, these insights help prioritize stabilization efforts as well as test reliability.
Key Strategies to Prevent and Fix Test Flakiness
Flaky tests undermine the reliability of test suites, leading to wasted time and decreased confidence in automated testing. A strategic approach is needed to prevent tests from becoming unstable, irrelevant, and untrustworthy.
The root causes to work on are finding, and best practices to follow that can reduce flakiness and improve test reliability by a lot. Using these strategies helps prevent and fix flaky tests successfully.
1. Pinpointing the Root Cause Through Isolation
Run flaky tests by themselves to isolate failures. Tests can be separated to determine if the problem lies in dependencies or test logic.
2. Improving Synchronization and Timing
Make sure tests are properly waiting and synchronized to avoid timing issues. Be explicit about waits rather than sleeping arbitrarily.
3. Mocking External Dependencies
Instead of making real API calls, databases, etc., use mocks or stubs. It takes away external factors and allows tests to be more predictable and stable.
4. Refactoring Tests for Independence and Clarity
Write self-contained tests that do not depend on shared resources. Clear, modular tests reduce unintended dependencies and improve maintainability.
5. Enhancing Assertions to Improve Test Reliability
This makes weak assertions lead to tests passing or failing inconsistently. Validating the expected results—very precisely, not imprecisely—helps strengthen assertions, and therefore, tests only fail when there is a real problem.
How to Maintain a Flaky Test?
Even while fixing flaky tests should be the priority, from time to time they need to be temporarily managed until a permanent fix is in place. Maintenance helps to avoid disruptions to the development workflow.
Regularly Monitor Test Outcomes
- Create a track history for the test results to check for trends.
- Look for inconsistencies in CI/CD dashboards or test reports.
- Alert when tests fail even too frequently.
Schedule Periodic Review
- Include flaky tests on a dedicated backlog for periodic investigation.
- Make sure that they are reviewed and acted upon by assigning ownership.
- Create a mechanism to focus on the high-impact flaky tests.
Update Tests Alongside Code
- Test logic should evolve with the application code.
- Rewrite old assertions or dependencies that might be responsible for flakiness.
- Keep the version of the test framework compatible with the application.
Document and Communicate Flaky Tests
- To avoid wasting debugging efforts, label flaky tests in test reports.
- Put the known flaky tests into the issue tracker or test suite.
- Tell the team so that they do not have to rework anything unnecessary or get confused.
{{cta-image-second}}
Final Thought
One crucial aspect of reliable software development is testing flaky tests. By actively finding and fixing flaky tests, you can maintain how your testing processes should be, as well as continuous integration.
Automation, utilization of advanced AI testing tools, and maintenance of regular tests in your development cycle make a sufficient impact on your development lifecycle. These will help you become a more productive, happier team and achieve faster and more effective releases of software.
.svg)
.svg)